Home / NFL teams / Indianapolis Colts

Indianapolis Colts ATS record & betting trends 2026

The Indianapolis Colts are 2–6 straight up and 4–4 against the spread (50.0%) in 2026, and the over is 5–3 in their games. Since 1999, the Colts are 245–216–12 ATS (53.1%): 117–112–4 at home, 152–131–8 as a favorite and 93–84–4 as an underdog. Their best ATS season was 2009 at 12–6–1.

Next game: vs Dallas Cowboys, Sunday, November 8, 1:00pm ET. Colts +5.5, total 52.5.
Since 1999 the Colts are 3–4 straight up and 3–4 ATS against the Cowboys; last meeting L 19–54 (Dec 2022). Backtest Colts at home vs Cowboys →

Indianapolis Colts 2026 game log

WeekDateOpponentSpreadTotalResultATSO/U
1Sep 13vs Baltimore Ravens+348.5 L 23–41LOver
2Sep 20@ Kansas City Chiefs+646.5 L 30–33WOver
3Sep 27vs Houston Texans+1.541.5 W 19–17WUnder
4Oct 4@ Washington Commanders-4.546.5 W 30–13WUnder
5Oct 11@ Pittsburgh Steelers+341.5 L 22–34LOver
6Oct 18vs Tennessee Titans-6.543.5 L 20–26LOver
7Oct 25@ Minnesota Vikings+6.541.5 L 10–16WUnder
8Nov 1@ Jacksonville Jaguars+1045.5 L 7–42LOver
9Nov 8vs Dallas Cowboys+5.552.5 1:00pm ET——
10Nov 15vs Miami Dolphins—— 1:00pm ET——
11Nov 19@ Houston Texans—— 8:15pm ET——
12Nov 29vs New York Giants—— 1:00pm ET——
14Dec 13@ Philadelphia Eagles—— 1:00pm ET——
15Dec 20@ Tennessee Titans—— 1:00pm ET——
16Dec 27vs Cincinnati Bengals—— 1:00pm ET——
17Jan 3@ Cleveland Browns—— 1:00pm ET——
18Jan 10vs Jacksonville Jaguars—— 1:00pm ET——

Colts against the spread by situation

Situation2026 ATS2026 O/USince 1999 ATSATS %Since 1999 O/U
All games4–45–3245–216–1253.1%242–226–5
Home1–22–1117–112–451.1%108–123–2
Away2–23–1125–101–855.3%132–99–3
As favorite1–11–1152–131–853.7%145–144–2
As underdog3–34–293–84–452.5%97–81–3
Divisional games1–22–184–84–550.0%82–90–1
Primetime (7pm ET+)1–01–048–32–360.0%45–36–2
Playoffs——14–1450.0%9–18–1

Indianapolis Colts ATS record by season since 1999

SeasonStraight upATSATS %Over–underPoints per game
20262–64–450.0%5–320.1–27.8
20258–99–852.9%9–827.4–24.2
20248–99–852.9%10–722.2–25.1
20239–89–852.9%11–623.3–24.4
20224–12–16–1135.3%7–1017.0–25.1
20219–810–758.8%8–926.5–21.5
202011–69–852.9%10–727.9–22.9
20197–97–7–250.0%9–722.6–23.3
201811–79–8–152.9%8–1025.9–21.2
20174–128–850.0%6–1016.4–25.3
20168–87–8–146.7%9–725.7–24.5
20158–88–850.0%8–820.8–25.5
201413–612–6–166.7%9–9–127.1–23.0
201312–611–761.1%10–825.4–23.5
201211–611–664.7%6–1121.5–24.2
20112–146–1037.5%7–915.2–26.9
201010–78–8–150.0%10–6–126.5–23.8
200916–312–6–166.7%10–925.4–18.8
200812–57–8–246.7%8–923.2–18.9
200713–49–852.9%8–927.9–17.1
200616–412–860.0%9–1126.6–21.3
200514–310–758.8%6–1126.9–15.8
200413–510–7–158.8%12–631.9–21.9
200314–511–7–161.1%11–828.4–21.1
200210–76–1135.3%7–8–220.5–20.8
20016–106–1037.5%13–325.8–30.4
200010–79–852.9%8–8–126.2–20.5
199913–410–6–162.5%8–925.8–20.7

Test a Colts betting angle

Records like these are a starting point, not a prediction: short-term ATS streaks swing a lot by chance. Test an idea over more games in the backtester: Colts at home, Colts on the road, Colts as a home underdog, or compare every team on the NFL ATS records page. For player props, see player prop hit rates.

Graded against closing lines (nflverse data), games through November 1, 2026, updated daily. Snap Theory is a research site; we don't take bets or sell picks. 21+.